Main Hall
Stalin Grandson
Stalin Grandson VS. Novaya Gazeta
Charge: Your newspaper has defamed Stalin
Yevgeny Dzhugashvili says an article claiming Stalin personally ordered the deaths of Soviet citizens is a lie.A Moscow court has agreed to hear the case against the opposition newspaper Novaya Gazeta
Novaya Gazeta
Case Status: CLOSED
Case Opened By: Wendy Mad on October 11, 2009
Bookmark Subscribe Widget
Closed Case
Time Left For Court Rulling Ruled on
October 18 2009
Guilty: 3 Not Guilty: 4
Novaya Gazeta was found
Not Guilty

CASE SUMMARY
Votings:
Guilty: 3
Not Guilty: 4
Arguments:
Prosecution Arguments: 1
Defense Arguments: 2
Total Arguments Strength:
Prosecution: 1
Defense: 0

CASE HIGHLIGHTS

PROSECUTION
Most Active Member of the Prosecution:
Wendy Mad
1 Arguments
Stronget Prosecution Argument: (Strength: 1)
Wendy Mad
 Stalin for many people is the symbol of an honest and fair leader
Posted by Wendy Mad 
Most Opposed Prosecution Argument: (1 Opposing Arguments)
Wendy Mad
 Stalin for many people is the symbol of an honest and fair leader
Posted by Wendy Mad 
 

DEFENSE
Most Active Member of the Defense:
Matt U. Seed
1 Arguments

CASE ARGUMENTS

PROSECUTION
Wendy Mad
 Stalin for many people is the symbol of an honest and fair leader
Posted by Wendy Mad 10 Months ago.
This Argument is: 
Strength:
1
Opposing Arguments:
View (1)
 

DEFENSE
Sort By:   Newest |  Strongest |  Most Opposed To
Swatjester
 Honest and fair? Are you insane? Stalin was one of the most brutal dictators in history, estimated of killing between 20 and 60 million victims. His gulags are the symbols of harsh dictatorships. There is nothing fair and honest about someone who imprisons others for political and personal vendettas. That is a violation of human rights.It is an abomination before history to present Stalin to people without identifying his status as one of the most abusive and murderous dictators of all time.
Posted by Swatjester 10 Months ago.  as a reply to this argument 
This Argument is: 
Strength:
0
Opposing Arguments:
 (0)
Matt U. Seed
 If the court finds for plaintiff, it will be a massive bomb. We should put an end to these discussions about the murderous dictator - he should be condemned.We should have our own Nuremberg, and not only for Stalin - for his whole regime
Posted by Matt U. Seed 10 Months ago.
This Argument is: 
Strength:
0
Opposing Arguments:
 (0)
 
About  |   Contact Us  |   Terms of Use  |   Advertise Here All Rights Reserved to "AllRise" © 2008